The Paper Store

Stef Dawson

as Annalee Monegan

Penn Badgley

as Sigurd Rossdale

Richard Kind

as Prof. Marty Kane

Caitlin Mehner

as Emily

Lev Pakman

as Joe's Buddy

Clifton Dunn

as Hooper

Lex Friedman

as Snotty TA

Emma Adele Galvin

as Carla

Patrick Hogue

as Bishop